Nothing to Die For

Fantasy and historical fiction resonate with male audiences because they feature brave, selfless leaders who inspire those in their charge to great heights of glory for noble causes that matter. There is a reason why stories like The Lord of the Rings, Braveheart, Gladiator, The Odyssey, The Iliad, Master and Commander, Captain Blood, action fare like Commando and Rambo, and even superhero stuff are so popular with men: they fill a need for adventure, bravery, and purpose in a gray, boring world of efficiency, production deadlines, and self-serving leaders who openly despise those beneath them.

These two features of the modern world—a lack of purpose and a lack of leadership—go hand-in-hand. First, the modern world is boring. A man is born, spends their entire youth in school following the rules laid down for him, goes to a university that trains them to be a cog in the machine, enters the workforce for 40 or 50 years, and then dies.

And what is this man working for? What are they hoping to attain? A house of their own? A little land? A family? This stuff can be achieved, but it’s difficult because everything has a high cost. Bills, mortgages, loans, debt, interest, and of course taxes. A man in the 21st century is just as much a slave as the peasant who had to work the land. However, instead of a feudal lord who at least offers to physically protect the land and those in it from invading barbarians in exchange for a share of a man’s crops, a man today toils at gunpoint for a regime populated by people who hate him and invite the barbarians in to settle next door.

Economic Man is a wreck, less-free than his ancestors.

“Look how much better our material circumstances are!” one might say. I agree that this is a good thing, to a point. Indoor plumbing, modern sanitation practices, and a good chunk of modern medicine are the things that I, personally, would have difficulty living without. I can take or leave the rest of it.

Herein underscores the crux of the problem with the boring nature of modernity. Yes, there is a lot of economic activity. Too much, perhaps. We feel chained to our jobs, especially those of us in the rapidly-expanding service economy. I refuse to call it the “knowledge” economy because very little of the information that passes through our channels of communication approaches the level of knowledge. We can only mention the word “wisdom” to lament its absence.

The end result of this economic activity is materialism, the substitute of stuff for actual meaning. One can have a giant house (financed by debt), an education from a top-tier university (financed by debt), a shiny new car or two, a boat, a vacation home (again, all financed by debt) and still be miserable. Maybe a wife and kids are in the picture. But even though having a family helps add meaning to life, if a man has no spiritual purpose and is relying on the accumulation of physical goods to fill that hole, they’re destined for unhappiness.

Our leaders (more on them later) have fooled us into thinking economic well-being in the form of the GDP is the equivalent of happiness, of the good life, of thumos, flourishing. A few generations have shown us that this is a hollow substitute for actual spirituality. In what used to be called Christendom, this had been found through the worship of Jesus Christ the Son of God. As recently as your great-grandparents generation, men thought they were fighting for the glory of the Lord. They might not have had as much stuff as we do, and what they had was not as advanced, but they were arguably more fulfilled.

Life can be harder yet still filled with more meaning. Ease and comfort is not an essential component of happiness and contentedness.

Those days are gone. So enter escapism. As it has been said elsewhere, there are no dragons anymore, but man still has the need to slay them.

This brings us to our leaders. Why do characters like Aragorn, Maximus, Odysseus, the doomed Hector, and even Captain America strike such a nerve with men? There are two main reasons: first, they have earned their positions through competency, and second they actually care about their people. Much like great military leaders of the past like Napoleon Bonaparte, Alexander the Great, Julius Caesar Genghis Khan, George Patton, Robert E. Lee, Ulysses S. Grant, and George Washington, these fictional men are able to inspire because they lead by example.

A modern man stuck in the boring, gray world of the post-industrial economy looks around and sees boring, gray leaders, men and women with no actual accomplishments save for going to the right schools and coming from the right families with the right connections, ruling over them. Utterly incompetent morons hold the power of life and death over a man, and they are there because they have convinced fifty-percent-plus-one of the population to vote for them.

Further, a man understands deep down that voting merely provides a patina of credibility and approval to what the ruling class was going to do anyway.

What we have is a noble class minus the actual nobility and everything that word entails. There is no sense of duty on the part of these leaders, no love of their people. Oftentimes, our leaders are not even of the same people. They are there to enrich themselves, the big money interests who helped them get to their position, and a small slice of their constituency. There is no servant-leadership in these United States, only self-serving leadership.

Is it any wonder why what are derisively called “guy” books or movies stubbornly remain so damn popular?

The recent glee, some ironic and some regrettably serious, to Afghanistan’s Taliban driving the United States out of their country after a twenty-year occupation, provides a similar example of this phenomenon. Nobody serious in the United States would rather live in Afghanistan under the Taliban; our regime is horrible and destructive, but it beats the alternative. This is not to say that the United States are the good guys in this situation either. There are no good guys. But a man suffering in the stultifying confines of American society can’t help but look and see these virile, adventurous men with their guns and cool uniforms storming into Kabul to drive out a technologically superior foe, the world’s sole superpower, and not feel their blood start to surge with the thrill of excitement.

Who are the leaders in America worth fighting and dying for? What are the causes worthy of your life?

An American Christian has a heavenly leader worth fighting and dying for. But we still spend the first part of our lives here on Earth in the material world. We need an earthly purpose combined with our spiritual one.

Here is another wrinkle: men interact with each other through hierarchies. Men judge the status of other men they meet, gauge it against their own, and fall in line accordingly. All hierarchies need leaders at the top, they need lieutenants loyal to the leader, and they need men who will do as they are told in exchange for respect of their competency.

Hierarchies are inevitable. It would just be nice to have leaders at the top who actually belong there.

– Alexander

5 8 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
8 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Raymond Solar
Raymond Solar(@dr_solar_man_of_the_atom)
3 months ago

Pertinent and cogent article, Alex! Thank you!

Roll this into the interminable Campbellian “Hero’s Journey” that Hollyweird uses (or rather misreads and misuses) and the perpetual reboots that entertainment does (specifically movies and comic books). If there are no real consequences, then the event has no value and no meaning. Men and boys especially resonate with this.

Myth and historic tales had meaning because the world was changed for better or worse by the actions of the characters in the story. Heroism meant you might help to make the world a better place. Your “Economic Man” only knows that Movie Y and Book Z sold well, so ‘let’s do it again’. The past is erased to make way for the new hotness. [Insert Red Letter Media — “Get Excited for New Product” meme here.]

Create stories with meaning and real consequences, and the audience will see the difference.

Xavier Basora
Xavier Basora(@xavierbasora)
3 months ago

Alexander

Fascinating article. You touch many themes that resonate with me. And I’m exploring in my novels/creative writing. About hiereacy Brian just posted an article about old money that compliments your post.

However let me begin Mediterranean anarchist and be very skeptical of hierarchies. I’ve always regarded them as largely illegitimate even if necessary.
The very important questions
1) are hierarchies ever legitimate?
2) who do they really benefit?
3) hierarchies ossify into insufferable caste systems where the top people not only perpetuate but make damn sure the castes remain fixed forever
4) gamma/soyboy/effeminate crisis is precisely because the hierarchies are ossified into castes. So the marginal guy who could’ve transformed into less gamma or even deltas are locked out and stagnate This dynamic parallels the male/female sexual dynamic where both are increasingly dysfunctional mentally morally and physically.

Eventually the ossified casteism will blow up as it’s contrary to reality. Hierarchies are like springs there has to be some movement for people to go up, down or even laterally. when the spring stops or is too compressed it breaks

xavier

Xavier Basora
Xavier Basora(@xavierbasora)
3 months ago

Alexander

Thanks for taking the time to respond to my long post.
You’ve helped me to reevaluate my thinking. And I need to reflect my presuppositions.

My worry is man’s fallen nature creates a tense cyclical relationship where hierarchies and elites was and wane.
I guess I’m deeply bothered by the cyclical nature and have to accept there’s no solution until our Lord comes. In the meantime I need to balance my disdain, contempt and suspicion for hierarchy with complying with rightful authority.

I need to work on this gamma ressentiment tendency. So I’ll introspect in the meantime.

xavier

Xavier Basora
Xavier Basora(@xavierbasora)
3 months ago

Alexander,

Thanks. The events in Kabul not only repulse me, but fill me with a lot of foreboding. China will definitely invade and occupy Taiwan and will compel the Pakistani to eventually invade Kashmir to distract the Indians and others through strategic deception.
The Iranians and the Arabs will settle their long war in the ugliest possible manner, and so on.

So the world has become far more dangerous, and I’m exasperated I can’t leave a better place for my kids. All well and nice to reform our homes, but is it enough, and will we cultivate new elites in time?

xavier

Take a look at my books

Indie Aversion

Meet a new person and spend more than five minutes with them, and if they’re a musician—much like with vegans, crossfitters, atheists, and homosexuals—they’ll find

Read More »

Writing Advice

“All right, men: we’re down by 5 with ninety seconds left. You know what to do.” Power forward Reginald Perkins, number 11, raises two fingers.

Read More »

Point B

A wave of early evening tiredness overcame me, and I began to dream. . . * * * Squid Game. The Hunger Games. The Most

Read More »